A class action settlement has
been funded for the benefit of First City Bank retirement plan participants. To
determine your eligibility, please complete and have notarized the Claim Form [click
to download for printing] , returning it by mail to : First City Class
Action Settlement, 909 Fannin, Suite 3150, Houston, Texas 77010.
You must also complete the
IRS Form W-9. [click to download for printing]
Your fully executed Claim
Form and W-9 must be received on or before December 18, 2009 or you will NOT
receive a payment.
The Notice [click
to download for printing or reading] provides details of the settlement.
We will also assist you if
you call (800) 324-5080 or (713) 351-7100.
Category #1
Documents of Greatest Importance to
Class Members
1.
Notice to Class Members Approved by Judge Schaffer in his October 16,
2009 Amended Preliminary Hearing Approval Order (the “Notice”).
This is the Notice to Class Members filed in the 152nd Judicial District
Court of Harris County and approved by Judge Schaffer on October 15,
2009.
2.
Amended Notice of Hearing, dated October 19, 2009, Scheduling a November
12, 2009 Class Action Settlement Fairness Hearing in Judge Schaffer’s
152nd Judicial District Court (the “Notice of Hearing”). This is
a copy of the Amended Notice of a Class Action Hearing in the 152nd
Judicial District Court of Harris County.
2B.
Second Amended Notice of Hearing, dated October 27, 2009. This is
a copy of the Second Amended Notice of a Class Action Hearing in the 152nd
Judicial District Court of Harris County.
3. The Claim Form, as
proposed by Class Counsel, subject to revision by Judge Schaffer during
the November 12, 2009 Class Action Settlement Fairness Hearing (the
“Claim Form”).
4.
Internal Revenue Service Form W-9 (the “W-9”) (which the Claim
Administrator will ask all Class Members to execute and deliver along
with a valid, fully-filled out Claim Form bearing an original, blue-ink
or black-ink signature).
5.
The Settlement Agreement Executed on September 21/22, 2009 (the
“Settlement”). The Agreement and Stipulation of Settlement
executed by counsel for all parties on September 21-22, 2009, evidencing
a settlement among FCLT Loans Asset Corporation (“FCLT”), FirstCity
Financial Corporation (“FCFC”), JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A. (“Chase”),
and Timothy J. Blair, Individually and as the Class Representative on
behalf of the Class (the “Class Representative”). This is the class
action settlement for which all parties seek approval.
6.
Amended Preliminary Hearing Approval Order signed by Judge Schaffer on
October 16, 2009 (the “Hearing Approval Order”). The First
Amended Preliminary Hearing Approval Order Providing for Notice and
Hearing in Connection with Settlement Hearing, signed by Harris County
District Court Judge Bob Schaffer. This is the order that will govern
the November 12, 2009 Class Action Settlement Fairness Hearing.
7. The Revised
Calendar – a History of Case Events (the “Calendar”).
8. Proposed Final
Judgment (“Proposed Final Judgment”). This is the proposed
“Final Judgment” filed in the 152nd Judicial District Court on October
15, 2009, that is, the proposed judgment that the parties seek to have
Judge Schaffer approve at the end of the November 12, 2009 Class Action
Settlement Fairness Hearing.
Category #2
First City Bancorporation Plan and
Trust Documents, Correspondence, Prudential Documents, Pleadings,
Motions, Orders, Judgments, and Trial and Appellate Court
Docket Sheets and Record Excerpts
9.
Plaintiff Timothy J. Blair’s Verified Motion for an Amended, Preliminary
Hearing Approval Order Motion (the “Amended Motion for Approval Hearing
Order”). This is Third Party Plaintiff Timothy J. Blair’s
Verified Motion for an Amended, Preliminary Approval Order Concerning a
Class Action Settlement and for Approval of Notice and the Scheduling of
a Final Fairness Hearing, filed in the 152nd Judicial District Court of
Harris County on October 15, 2009.
10.
Plaintiff Timothy J. Blair’s Verified Motion for a Preliminary Hearing
Approval Order Motion (the “Original Motion for Approval Hearing
Order”). This is Third Party Plaintiff Timothy J. Blair’s
Verified Motion for an Amended, Preliminary Approval Order Concerning a
Class Action Settlement and for Approval of Notice and the Scheduling of
a Final Fairness Hearing, filed in the 152nd Judicial District Court of
Harris County on September 25, 2009.
11.
The October 7, 2009 Letter of Prudential Insurance Company Team Leader
Chris Gillen’s letter explaining the current status of Prudential’s list
of former First City annuitants (“Prudential’s October 7, 2009 Letter
about Class Members”).
12. The January 1, 1976
First City Bancorporation Employee Retirement Trust (the “1976 Trust”).
13. The January 1, 1983
First City Bancorporation Employee Retirement Plan (the “1983 Plan”).
14.
Prudential Insurance Company GAC # 5858. The former First City
employees’ Class Members’ Prudential Insurance Company Group Annuity
Contract No. GA-5858, reflecting a deposit in the amount of $18,336,340,
dated May 6, 1991.
15.
Prudential Insurance Company GAC # 5523. The former First City
employees’ Class Members’ Group Annuity Contract GAC # 5523, reflecting
a deposit in the amount of $2,686,486, dated May 6, 1991.
16.
Prudential Insurance Company’s 1991 correspondence and certificate forms
for annuitants under GAC # 5858.
17.
The Joint Plan of Reorganization by First City Bancorporation of Texas
in the In Re First City Bancorporation of Texas, Inc., Debtor
bankruptcy case, Case No. 392-39474-HCA-11, in the U.S. District Court
for the Northern District of Texas, Dallas Division, dated May 5, 1995.
18.
Prudential Insurance Company booklet entitled Important Information
about Prudential’s Plan of Reorganization. This is a copy of
Prudential Insurance Company’s booklet explaining its purposes for
reorganizing as a demutualized corporation under New Jersey law.
19.
Prudential Demutualization Booklet. This is a copy of Prudential
Insurance Company’s booklet entitled, Prudential’s Plan to
Demutualize: A Guide to Issues for Group Contract Holders and
Policyholders, as published by the Prudential Insurance Company.
20.
Internal Revenue Service Private Letter Ruling 200114002. This IRS
Private Letter Ruling, This private letter ruling, which does
not bind the IRS in its transactions, examined taxation and
demutualization issues as they applied to a mutual life insurance
company.
21.
First City President Robert W. Brown’s October 29, 2001 letter to Kevin
J. Griffin, Manager, Guaranteed Products, Prudential Insurance Company
of America.
22.
Prudential Financial, Inc.’s Petition in Interpleader. This is a
copy of the Plaintiff’s Original Petition that initiated Prudential
Financial, Inc.’s interpleader lawsuit against JPMorgan/Chase Bank, FCFC
and FCLT on January 19, 2005, along with all exhibits attached to that
pleading.
23.
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.’s Original Answer, Cross-Petition, and
Third-Party Petition for Declaratory Judgment, etc.
24.
Defendant FirstCity Financial Corporation’s First Amended Answer and
Cross-Claim.
25.
Timothy J. Blair’s Class Action Lawsuit. The lawsuit Third Party
Plaintiff Timothy J. Blair filed against FCLT and FCFC on September 2,
2005.
26. The
Index to the Clerk’s Record in the First Court of Appeals identifying
the key pleadings, motions, responses, orders, and judgment in the 152nd
Judicial District Court during 2005 and 2006.
27. First
City Financial Corporation’s Motion for Summary Judgment filed on
September 30, 2005.
28. Third
Party Defendant Timothy J. Blair’s Response to First City Financial
Corporation’s Motion for Summary Judgment and Defendant FCFC’s Motion
for Summary Judgment, as filed on September 30, 2005.
29. The
Reporter’s Record of the October 21, 2005 summary judgment hearing in
the case.
30. Judge
Ken Wise’s October 21, 2005 Order Granting Timothy J. Blair’s Motion for
Recognition of a Class Action Case.
31.
Judge Ken Wise’s August 14, 2006 Order Granting Defendant First City
Financial Corporation’s Motion for Summary Judgment.
32.
Judge Ken Wise’s August 14, 2006 Final Judgment.
33.
The Docket Sheet for the Case in the Texas First Court of Appeals.
34.
Appellant FCLT’s Appellant’s Brief, including FCLT’s “Chart of
Succession of Assets” and FCLT’s “Glossary and Sources of Terms in
Chart,” as filed on January 26, 2007.
35.
Retirement Plan-Beneficiaries Class-Representative Timothy J. Blair’s
Appellant’s Brief, filed on February 28, 2007.
36.
Appellee First City Financial Corporation’s Appellee’s Brief, filed on
April 6, 2007.
37.
Retirement Plan-Beneficiaries Class-Representative Timothy J. Blair’s
Reply Brief, filed on May 3, 2007.
38.
Blair’s counsel’s March 5, 2008 supplemental letter brief filed in the
First Court of Appeals. This is the letter-brief Blair’s counsel
filed to argue that Blair was entitled to receive all of the
demutualization funds as a result of the decision in Bank of New York v.
Janowick, 470 F.3d 264 (6th Cir. 2006), cert. denied sub nom. Southwire
Co. v. Janowick, -- U.S. -- , 128 S.Ct. 195, 169 L.Ed.2d 36 (U.S. Oct.
1, 2007) and post-Janowick decisions.
39.
The First Court of Appeals’ September 3, 2008 Order scheduling oral
argument for September 24, 2009.
40.
Appellant FCLT’s Supplemental Letter Brief dated September 9, 2008.
41.
The First Court of Appeals’ September 19, 2008 Order granting all
parties extended oral argument and the parties’ agreed motion requesting
it.
42.
The First Court of Appeals’ September 25, 2008 Memorandum Order of
Referral to Mediation.
43.
The parties’ Agreed Motion to Abate Appeal and Remand, filed on December
31, 2008.
44.
The parties’ February 17, 2009 letter of concern to the First Court of
Appeals.
45.
Appellant Timothy J. Blair’s April 9, 2009 supplemental letter brief to
the First Court of Appeals.
46.
The First Court of Appeals’ June 4, 2009 Judgment and Opinion.
47.
Robert S. MacIntyre Jr.'s Affidavit - Request for Compensation.
48.
Robert S. MacIntyre Jr.'s Affidavit - Proposed Compensation for Class
Counsel.
49.
David A. Furlow's Affidavit - Request for Compensation.
50.
Notice of Final
Judgment Notice of the Court’s November 30, 2009 Judgment
Approving Class Representative Timothy J. Blair’s and Class Counsel’s
Proposed Class Action Settlement
51. Final
Judgment Order of Final Approval and Final Judgment
|